Volvo XC60 or Audi Q5 for reliability and economy?

Hi,

I am researching 2020-2024 Audi Q5 TDI and Volvo XC60 for towing a horsebox and long commutes. Which SUV is more reliable and cheaper for servicing, mpg, etc?

Thanks.

Sarah Fanning (Carlow)

Jan 2025 Filed under: towing

---

Expert answer

Hi Sarah,

In terms of long commutes, and assuming you are sticking with the regular 2.0-litre diesel options, then our experience suggests that the Audi is more efficient - with the caveat that how you drive has a large influence on that. Overall, the Audi should prove fractionally cheaper to service and maintain, too.

Comparing the reliability between the two is less clearcut and the newer versions you can afford the better. Both cars are mechanically sound and most issues come from electronics etc. They’re comparable in short.

Shane O' Donoghue - Complete Car Advisor
@Shane_O_D