2009 BMW 535d or 2011 520d?

Would you buy a 2008-09 BMW 535d or a new 2011 520d? As you can see my budget is about €45k. I have been used to plenty of power in the past!

Paul

Paul Byrne (Drogheda)

Jun 2010 Filed under: choosing new car

---

Expert answer

Hi Paul,

That is a tough one. Do you opt for awesome power on one hand or do you choose the newer car with less power, but more finesse? The answer to this is really down to how much you value your €45,000. Once the new model settles into the market, which in truth will only happen when the 520d arrives properly in the next few weeks, then the value of the older model will drop and there will also be less demand for the more expensive versions such as the 535d. This had a home in the boom years but is pretty rare now and likely to be less sellable in the future.

Don't get me wrong; the 535d is a fabulous car, but I would have to be sensible and say get a new 520d. For a start it is much better value than the old car, is better equipped and is also more powerful than the old 520d. I drove the Touring version in Munich recently and while it isn't a rocket it is certainly fast enough. 

The only way I would buy a 535d would be if I was buying an older one. Here is a 2006 model, with low mileage for €25,995. This would still be a nice car and you won't lose your shirt on it!

Paul, be sensible this time around and get the new car - you won't regret it.

Complete Car Adviser